🍦 In the heart of Pinecraft · Sarasota

Homemade scoops,
made with love.

Creamy, dreamy ice cream, thick shakes, malts & banana splits — served from our little yellow corner of Pinecraft for years on end.

4.6 ★ · 863 Google reviews
Scoop on down ↓
A hand holding a waffle cone with two scoops of creamy strawberry-swirl homemade ice cream at Pinecraft Ice Cream Shoppe An open tub of marbled pink, mint and chocolate homemade ice cream being scooped at Pinecraft
Our little yellow shoppe

A neighborhood scoop shop in Pinecraft.

Tucked into the sunny, bike-friendly streets of Pinecraft — Sarasota's beloved Amish-Mennonite snowbird community — our colorful little parlor has been the go-to spot for homemade ice cream done the old-fashioned way.

Everything is made by hand and the flavor board changes all the time, so there's always something new to fall in love with. Grab a cone, settle into one of the bright Adirondack chairs out front under the giant soft-serve sign, and watch the cruiser bikes roll by. It's the kind of simple, generous, family-time treat that's getting harder to find — and exactly why folks keep coming back, season after season.

4.6★863 happy reviews
$Famously fair prices
100%Homemade flavors
Loved by the neighborhood

863 reviews. 4.6 stars.

Don't just take our word for it — here's what folks are saying.

★★★★★

"This ice cream was an INCREDIBLE find! Immaculately clean, the service was friendly, helpful and efficient. The price was AMAZING for the quality — we fed our boy-family of 7 for under $35! What a fabulous treat."

C
Chloe Gonzalez2 months ago
★★★★★

"One of our favorite ice cream spots in town! We've been coming here since we moved to Sarasota 13 years ago. Ice cream time is family time, and this is our go-to spot — especially on those hot summer days."

L
Lucia GabrielaSarasota local
★★★★★

"BEST ICE CREAM IN ALL OF SARASOTA! The ice cream is homemade and new flavors are introduced very often. Prices are extremely low, the quality is amazing and they have fantastic customer service. You won't be disappointed!"

K
King PrimeVerified Google review
★★★★★

"What a fabulous ice cream experience! A wonderful selection of flavours makes it difficult to choose. We enjoyed sitting outside in the sunshine with the really generous 'small' servings. Really good prices too. Highly recommended."

J
John EdelmanVisitor favorite
★★★★★

"Oh yes, creamy creamy ice cream, just the way I like it, and there are so many flavors. Friendly reminder — on a hot day get a cup instead of a cone, because they're so soft and creamy they melt quickly!"

A
Anna XuGoogle review
★★★★★

Join the 800+ neighbors and snowbirds who keep coming back for the best homemade scoops in Pinecraft.

Your review next?We'd love to see you
Come find us

Right in the heart of Pinecraft.

Checking hours…
📍

Visit the Shoppe

3350 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239

Next to Yoder's Fresh Market · free parking out front

Call us

(941) 373-1878

For today's flavors, orders & questions

🕗

Hours

  • Monday11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
  • Tuesday11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
  • Wednesday11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
  • Thursday11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
  • Friday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Saturday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • SundayClosed
☎ Call 🧭 Directions
Enlarged photo from Pinecraft Ice Cream Shoppe
Questions? Ask our AI
Ask Sarasota Consulting
AI assistant · replies in seconds
✨ Make it yours — from $49/mo →
✨ Make it yoursfrom $49/mo →